I’m a big fan of data backup. Back in “the day” we used tape drives to backup our data. Tape drives are still extremely valuable and used by many organizations. Most small businesses, however, do not want to invest in or deal with the hassle of a tape drive (although I’d love to hear your stories about the value of tape backups!).
Since most of us aren’t using tape drives and with the falling prices on external hard drives and network attached storage (NAS) devices, putting a backup system in place for your home network is easier – and cheaper – than ever. And yet, most folks still are not backing up their precious pictures, important documents and vast music collections. Perhaps the networking and setup are too complicated, or perhaps the up-front expense is too much to justify. Whatever the reason, most families, organizations and small businesses are not backing up their data consistently.
This is where online backup services step up to the plate and, for the most part, hit homeruns. Their up-front cost is minimal ($50/year on the high end), their storage capacity is significant, with many offering unlimited storage space and their setup is often just a few clicks. The hardest part is deciding which service to go with, so I’ve decided to review five of the services that you should consider when looking at online backup. Any of the services below would serve you well. I have, however, ranked them specifically and intentionally from #5 to #1 based on my extensive usage of each of these programs as well as feedback from my clients.
5. Mozy
MozyHome – I mention Mozy primarily because it’s popular and they have good TV commercials. I’ve had clients use it and have no problem with it at all – it’s worked well and been reliable. On the Mac side of things, their client uploads are painfully slow. The first time I had a MacBook with about 90 GB worth of stuff to be backed up. After 8 weeks of an almost continuous broadband cable connection, Mozy was less than 50% complete in backing up. More recently, on a MacBook Pro, Mozy was also extremely slow, backing up at a rate that would take it almost 6 months to complete the initial backup. The other backup services here are much quicker. Mozy also offers a business version – MozyPro – that is licensed-based for multiple computers and can also handle servers. It’s cost is significantly more than it’s competition, however. On all fronts, I have a hard time recommending Mozy products.
Pros:
- Easy install
- Multi-platform
- Cheap MozyHome pricing ($4.95/mo./computer)
- Unlimited backup
Cons:
- Slow backup on Mac
- Pricy business solutions
- ($3.95/mo./computer + $0.50/GB/mo.)
- ($6.95/mo./server + $0.50/GB/mo.)
- Unable to backup external or network drives
- No multiple computer option under MozyHome
4. Carbonite
Carbonite – Formerly my backup program of choice for a long time, Carbonite offers unlimited backup in a cross-platform solution. Carbonite tags your files and folders with dots indicating the status of the backup across individual files. This is a very cool solution. If I’m in a folder on my hard drive, I can look and know immediately if the files in that folder are backed up, pending backup or not scheduled for backup. I can also tell Carbonite to backup certain files ASAP, so that I’m sure to not lose that critically important presentation I spent the last fourteen days working on.
For both Mac and PC, Carbonite is almost fool-proof in it’s execution of backup and restore. Restoring gives you the option to restore the file to its original location or somewhere else. Versioning also gives you the ability to restore older versions of the same file. For example, if you made some changes to an important presentation, Carbonite backs up that file. Then you find out that your previous version of the presentation actually went over better with your audience than your current version. No problem; Carbonite keeps previous versions of backed up files for three months, so you can choose which one to restore. Mozy keeps your file versions for one month, by comparison.
Carbonite does not backup external drives or network drives, which is a shame, because that is a key feature that is becoming increasingly essential. Carbonite also provides straightforward pricing – especially for business users. Carbonite Pro allows you to manage multiple computers under a single account with no per computer licensing fees – all you pay for is storage through a simple tiered plan where you could pay as little as $20/month or as much as $250/month.
Pros:
- Quick backup
- Easy-to-see backup status
- Fool-proof restore & file versioning
- Straightforward pricing
- Can backup servers for the same price as workstations
Cons:
- No external or network drive backups
- No ability to specify the types of files you want backed up
3. SpiderOak
SpiderOak is not one you find in a lot of online backup reviews, but it is worth a look both for its combination of unique features and pricing. It’s got a weird name, but SpiderOak is what I put many of my small business clients on for their remote backup. SpiderOak allows you to backup as many computers as you want under a single account with no licensing fees and cheap tiered pricing. For $10/mo (or $100 if you pay annually) you get 100 GB of space. You can have as many computers as you want backing up to that 100 GB chunk, which is fantastic for lots of small businesses and organizations. You can add another 100 GB of storage for just $10/month. When you look at options like MozyHome, with its unlimited storage option, SpiderOak may look expensive. But when you begin to factor in other computers in a business or organization, MozyPro can get very expensive fast. Even with Carbonite Pro, 100 GB of storage will run you $75 per month – SpiderOak gives it to you for $10 per month ($8.33/mo if you pay annually).
In addition to online backup, you also get file sharing and synchronization similar to Dropbox. They are also one of the very most secure backup solutions with a true “zero knowledge” system that makes sure the only thing SpiderOak knows about your data is how much space it occupies on their servers. They also use the highest level of encryption of any backup provider I have found, which is why I trust my clients to it.
Pros:
- Unlimited computers under a single account
- Extremely competitive pricing for small businesses
- “Zero knowledge” privacy & security system
- Highest level of encryption
- Ability to synchronize & share files across an organization
Cons:
- Somewhat unintuitive interface
- Not widely known (if this could be a con)
2. Backblaze
Backblaze is also one of those that doesn’t seem to get a lot of press from the typical corps of techno-bloggers and magazines, but it’s worth a look both for individuals and businesses. Backblaze gives you unlimited storage for $5/mo./computer and $50/computer/year for business users. Backup is quick (not the fastest, but pretty quick) and the interface is straightforward and intuitive. You have lots of options (including the ability to throttle your backup speed), but it’s not overwhelming. Backblaze also consumes very little in terms of resources while it is backing up, so you don’t feel bogged down while it’s working. It can also backup external and network drives, uses very strong encryption and saves multiple versions of your files.
Restoring files from Backblaze is a simple process, but it can only be completed through the web interface – there’s no option to restore your files through the application. This isn’t a big deal, but restoring your files right from within the application is a much more intuitive and streamlined process. In addition, programs such as Carbonite and CrashPlan offer to restore your files to their original location or to a different location (such as your Desktop). Backblaze allows you to download a zip file that will contain your restored files in a folder hierarchy identical to the one on your computer. That means you have to dig down to that folder on your computer and drag-n-drop the restored file to that location. That’s really cumbersome – especially if you are backing up lots of files at different locations.
Pros:
- Excellent pricing for businesses & individuals
- Super simple setup & backup
- Lots of options for advanced users
- Low resource overhead
Cons:
- No ability to restore files from within the application
- Cumbersome restore system
1. CrashPlan+
After my long-standing use of Carbonite, I switched to CrashPlan+. Why? CrashPlan+ supports external and networked drives and provides the ability to backup to my home server as well as CrashPlan’s own servers – but there were even more reasons that could have swayed me. CrashPlan+ offers features similar to many other providers: easy setup, file versioning, unlimited backup, strong encryption, easy restore, cross-platform, intuitive interface and quick backup. It took just over 30 days for my initial backup of 180 GB to complete on my MacBook Pro, which was not on all day every day – had I left my Mac on more, I think my initial backup could have been done in under 3 weeks.
There are several things that make CrashPlan stand out from the crowd:
- Backup external and network drives
- Extensive options, including bandwidth throttling, CPU usage, frequency and versioning, file name exclusions, data de-duplication, data verification, advanced security and more (whew!)
- The ability to create multiple backup sets with different destinations
- The ability to backup to a folder on your computer, a different computer on your network or a friend’s computer – all free options
- Seeded backup – CrashPlan will send you an encrypting external hard drive, you put your data on it and send it back to them, they load it on their servers and your backup picks up from where that external left off.
CrashPlan’s unique ability to backup to different destinations (or even to allow other people to backup to your computer) is awesome and it’s just as secure as backing up to CrashPlan’s own servers. Creating different backup sets would allow you to backup certain files online, certain other files to a friend’s computer and a third set of files to CrashPlan’s own servers. This type of redundancy is what data backup is all about. The interface is straightforward and simple, yet it provides you with the most options (by far) and the most information of any backup service reviewed here.
Pricing is competitive with everyone else, coming in at $5/mo./computer or the option to backup up to 10 computers for $12/month (that drops to $10/mo. if you pay annually) – all with unlimited storage.
Pros:
- External and network drive backup
- Extensive options
- Lots of information – they even provide you with a weekly email report of your backup progress
- Ability to create backup sets
- Backup to multiple destinations
- Ability to serve as a backup destination
- Seeded initial backup
- File versioning & ability to restore from within application
Cons:
- Not the cheapest backup solution
- Extensive options could be confusing for novice users
So, there you have it, The I.T. Rangers top five online backup providers. Put your input in the comments!
*Disclosure: Some of the links on this page are affiliate links; if you click on one and signup for that service, I get a small commission and you get a great product! It’s a win/win!